News:

No news is good news :-)

Main Menu

WMATA joins Google Transit

Started by Scrabbleship, May 11, 2011, 07:59:52 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Scrabbleship

I could link to the GGW celebration announcement post, but most of you have probably have seen it. This is a very soft launch as though directions are accessible the info isn't fully loaded (no icons for bus stops, no times when clicking on an [M] icon, etc.). Good to see though it'll be interesting to see when/if ART*, Connector**, and TheBus join up.


* ART released their data under a Creative Commons license for all developers a while back.
** Connector reportedly said that their releasing their data would hinge on WMATA joining.

WMATAGMOAGH

Yawn.

Seriously, Google Transit (and Google anything else) is overrated in my opinion.  I highly doubt any of the GGW bloggers have had the "pleasure" of trying to work with Google to set up a feed or creating the feed itself.  Playing with a final GTFS file isn't the same thing.  If your data can be easily put into that format, then it is great, but many transits have their data set up differently and chose their formats long before the advent of Google Transit and aren't going to change it overnight now to accommodate Google.  Also, there are many things in the agreement with Google that give pause to the people who actually have to sign the legal agreements, and the fact that a feed will only be updated once a week (though there are plans to make it twice a week, I don't know if that happened yet) is a huge turnoff.  How do I know all this?  Because I was almost tasked with creating a feed.  WMATA's hesitations were very justified.

WMATA has a perfectly serviceable trip planner.  There was no good reason that I can see that they needed to also put their data on Google Transit when they have plenty of other things to worry about. 

Tritransit Area

Here's the Metro Press Release: http://www.wmata.com/about_metro/news/PressReleaseDetail.cfm?ReleaseID=4919 complete with video statements from the GM and Board Chair.  WMATA seems happy about it.

The headaches in partnering with Google can be appreciated, though.

My favorite buses:
1989 SEPTA AN440: 19 years in service
1989 NJT Metro Bs: 21 years in service
1990 WMATA 93/9400 Flxes: 20 years in service!
1990-92 Ride-On Orion Is: 17-18 years in service!

Tell me again I have no taste in buses...